Everyone is saying Shanks will come to save Luffy but at the same moment everyone has forget that Elbaf is Shanks’ backyard. Its his claimed territory and giants love him, Shanks has a history on that island and right now it’s being torn apart. So where is he?
Read Disclaimer before continuing
Spoilers ahead for the Elbaf arc up to Chapter 1198. Everything beyond what the manga has shown is currently speculation only.
The usual answer is that Oda wants the Straw Hats to carry the arc and that’s probably true but thats one reason we can thought of for now, what if there’s an in-story reason too, like if Shanks can’t go to Elbaf because he can’t safely get close to Imu. This thing has a possibility too because of the mark on his arm, which got cut off while saving Luffy in starting of the One Piece.
What we know about the Mark
We know that Imu’s contracts come in levels and Shanks held the lowest one. Shanks and Harald were both first given the shallows covenant, marked by a cross with a circle in the centre. That cross shows up on Shanks’ arm in Chapter 1152 and on Harald’s in Chapter 1167. Deeper covenants seem to bring more: Harald later took the depths contract, and the Holy Knights wear its symbol on their armbands. On other hand, Gorosei sit on a deeper level.

We have to look at Shanks’ mark first. It was on his left arm, the same arm he later lost saving Luffy from a Sea King in the very first chapter. That’s hard to ignore as a coincidence. A mark that never reappears after the arm is gone suggests the bond was cut.
Now here come the King of Elbaf: Harald
Harald is the key to the whole theory even with a deeper contract, he regained control of himself for a while after Loki cut off his arm, until the arm grew back. This incident shows the level of connection to Imu.
If that’s true, removing the lowest level mark could free someone for good and Shanks wouldn’t regenerate it because nobody has shown that the shallows contract gives regeneration at all. For this reason Shanks might have lost hia arm for good. We also know he met and befriended Harald in Mary Geoise, so its possible he knows what Imu’s control can do to a person.
The Sea King Angle
This is where the theory gets shaky, so treat it carefully. Some fans wonder whether the sea can break Imu’s hold. The covenant names hint at ocean depths and that echoes the popular theory that Imu is tied to a Sea God. If the sea can strip Devil Fruit powers, maybe it can strip a contract too and a Sea King’s bite could be the one thing that cuts the mark away. This theory has plenty of holes for now. Because this arises a question, which had not beed answered yet, how could have Shanks even know it would work?
For now, we can believe it to be as his biggest gamble of his life otherwise someone that strong cant loose his arm to a Sea King, who just got scared by his eyes later.
Coming back to our latest Chapter 1198
Look at where Elbaf stands. Imu is now on the island in a third form with huge horns and he asks Loki about ancient technology on Elbaf before knocking him out in one blow. Imu was eager to return to Mary Geoise soon or his life will be in danger. Imu is physically there, which is exactly the situation Shanks would want to avoid.
Here’s my reasoning
Shanks may be free but he can’t be completely sure. Harald showed that Imu’s power can reach people whose contracts are still active. If there’s any chance the old bond still responds to Imu’s presence then walking into Elbaf could hand Imu an Emperor. For Shanks, staying away might be the safest move for everyone rather than a cowardice.
Probably Straw Hats have to do it alone that’s why
If Shanks arrived, the Straw Hats would quickly turn into spectators, since he could deal with the Holy Knights and give Imu a much harder fight. This is Luffy’s story, so Oda needs Shanks sidelined and “he can’t get close to Imu” is a clean in world way to do it. It even matches the early hints for the next chapter, which say something unusual happens to Imu and Luffy.
What we believe
From all this we doesn’t say Shanks is weak. He only wants to stay careful here, after all its a God level threat. A man who gave up his arm to escape Imu’s control wouldn’t gamble it back on a battlefield where Imu is standing in person. Until Shanks shows up or doesn’t, we can only watch Luffy’s new form and Imu’s countdown.




Leave a Reply